My Favorite Shelf-Stable Buttercream Frosting Recipe - Better Baker Club (2024)

This shelf stable buttercream frosting recipe is similar to a classic American buttercream, but it’s safe to use in a cottage bakery.

If you are a home baker who follows cottage food laws then this fluffy, white frosting is sure to become one of your favorite go-to recipes!

Be sure and try my shelf-stable chocolate frosting too! It’s perfect for chocolate cake or chocolate cupcakes!

Cottage food-approved recipes

The question I get asked most by cottage food bakers is: How can I make my recipes taste like they should when I can’t use the ingredients I love?

Selling baked goods from your home means you might need to make some changes to your recipes to adhere to your state cottage food laws.

Don’t give up on your bakery dreams, just find good cottage foods-friendly recipes instead!

Here are a few of my favorites:

Easy Chocolate Icing Recipe: No Butter

Dairy-Free Sugar Cookies

Royal IcingRecipe with Meringue Powder

Do you have questions about starting a home bakery business?

Do you feel like you have more questions than answers about starting a home bakery business?

If you want to find out what it really takes to start and run a bakery business from home, then grab my Ultimate Hobby to Hustle Handbook!

Jump to Recipe

My professional baker’s frosting recipe

If you’ve been around my website before, you probably know that I used to own and operate a chain of cupcake shops.We were known throughout the Midwest for our buttercream frosting and people went BANANAS for it! The recipe that I’m sharing today isn’t the same (because that one had butter and milk) but the baker’s technique is the same.

Is buttercream shelf-stable

American buttercream recipes (made from whipped butter, heavy cream, and confectioner’s sugar) are technically not shelf stable, but they can be kept at room temperature in an airtight container. The high sugar content acts to preserve the cream and butter making it safe to consume without refrigeration for several days.

Shelf-stable foods, however, are those that can safely be stored at room temperature in an airtight container for an extended period of time. This fluffy frosting recipe has no dairy ingredients that require refrigeration, so once you mix the recipe you can store it unrefrigerated for up to 7 days.

How do I make grocery store-style buttercream frosting

This frosting recipe tastes like the kind found in grocery stores because of the way it is whipped. It creates a very smooth pipe-able frosting that is easy to work with.

To make it, place all the ingredients in the bowl of a stand mixer and mix on low speed to combine. Once everything is well combined, switch to the whisk attachment and mix on high speed until you have a fluffy, white buttercream.

What is the most stable buttercream frosting

Ask any baker and they will probably tell you that they have different frostings for different uses. One of the types of frosting I often needed was heat-stable frosting.

Summertime weddings that get set up outside require cakes and cupcakes that can hold up to warm weather.

This recipe holds up well in warm weather and is perfect for things like outdoor summer weddings or selling cupcakes at the farmer’s market.

Does Buttercream frosting need to be refrigerated?

This non-refrigerated frosting recipe can be stored at room temperature in a sealed container for 7 days.

To save time, it can also be mixed in bulk and stored in the refrigerator or freezer.

How to add flavor to buttercream frosting

If you’d like to change the flavor of this buttercream frosting you can! Just mix it according to the recipe directions, and then add your flavoring of choice.

My favorite flavorings are baker’s emulsions. An emulsion is like an extract but instead of the flavoring being suspended in an alcohol base, it is suspended in a water base.

This is great for frosting flavoring because you do not cook the alcohol out of the recipe as you would with baked goods.

Lorann Oils makes the best emulsions!

Here are a few of my favorite ways to add different flavors:

• Almond Bakery Emulsion- love this in cookie frosting!
• Princess Cake and Cookie Bakery Emulsion– give your frosting a wedding cake flavor!
• Cheesecake Flavor–for cottage foods safe cream cheese frostings.
• Coffee Bakery Emulsion- perfect for that rich mocha flavor.
• Butter Bakery Emulsion– add richness to vanilla frosting.
• Lemon Bakery Emulsion – amazingly intense tangy lemon flavor.

You can also combine the flavor oils for a more unique taste. I like Princess, Lemon, and Almond for a signature wedding cake flavor.

Be careful! The flavors are very concentrated, so a little goes a long way. Start with just a drop or two and add more if needed.

Hi-ratio shortening for a creamier frosting

I like using a high ratio shortening whenever possible because it acts more like real butter in the recipe. If you can find it, you will get a glossier and smoother frosting.

If you can’t get high-ratio frosting, then you can substitute a more traditional vegetable shortening like Crisco. It will work for the recipe, but won’t have the same creamy mouthfeel and texture.

Final thoughts

If you are looking for a professional baker’s frosting recipe that is similar to grocery store frosting, then give this shelf stable frostinga try! You’ll love the convenience of non-refrigerated ingredients, and your customers will love that it tastes like their favorite bakery-style whipped frosting.

Don’t be discouraged if you are a home baker and your list of prohibited ingredients doesn’t allow you to bake like you are accustomed to. Just swap out your old recipes for new cottage bakery-friendly recipes like this one!

If you liked this recipe let me know in the comments and be sure and check out my Chocolate Shelf-Stable Frosting too!