The Very Best Italian Cream Soda Recipe (2024)

It’s that time of year when I want to share my Italian Cream Soda Recipe with you. It’s festive, fairly cheap, and kids and grandkids love making these. These are perfect for family get-togethers and even family reunions.

The very first time I had an Italian Cream Soda was at a restaurant. Mark and I had taken our kids and grandkids to an Italian restaurant for dinner. The server asked if we wanted Italian sodas. Of course, we wanted to hear all about them. From that day forward our family was hooked.

Of source, I had to see how they were made because obviously, they are cheaper to make at home, right? They only take four ingredients to make them, of course, we also love adding whipping cream and a cherry on top, right?

I love that we can choose our own flavors and make them right at the table. An Italian Soda is a soft drink made with carbonated water, half and half, and flavors of your choice with a creamy texture and topped with whipping cream.

In case you missed my winter or fall drink post, How To Make The Best Hot Chocolate

Kitchen Items You May Need:

• Festive-Straws
• Glasses 6-8 inches tall
• Measuring Spoons
• Torani Sweetened Syrups

Italian Cream Soda Recipe

Step One: Gather Ingredients

Gather your ingredients to make the Italian Cream Sodas. All you need is Club Soda, Torani Sweetened Syrup, Half & Half, ice cubes, whipping cream, and Maraschino Cherries.

Step Two: Put Ice Cubes in Glass

Choose a glass that is at least 6-8 inches tall. Add the ice cubes to your glass.

Step Three: Add Club Soda

Next, add the Club Soda on top of the ice cubes.

See Also

Spinach & Chicken Curry Recipe {Chicken Saag} - Cookin Canuck100 Healthy Instant Pot RecipesEasy Oven Cooked Beef Brisket Recipe -The Foodie AffairEasy Slow Cooker Spicy Turkey Chili Recipe - Chowhound

Step Four: Pick Sweet Syrup

Choose your favorite Torani Sweetened Syrup and add 3 tablespoons to your glass. You can mix or match many flavors together.

Step Five: Add Half & Half

Add one tablespoon of Half & Half to your glass, and let it float to the bottom. DO NOT STIR, yet.

Finished Product

Add some whipping cream to the top of the drink along with a Maraschino Cherry, if desired. Mix or stir right before you take a sip! Festive-colored straws are the finishing touch! Enjoy!

Are Italian Cream Sodas actually Italian?

Actually, no they are not! LOL! The company Torani, crafted this popular drink about 50 years ago because of the extensive flavors that Torani had produced. The company is based out of California. You can choose so many flavors, it’s so fun to make these drinks, and many others, with their sweetened and sugar-free flavorings.

What makes Italian Soda different from regular soda?

They are both made with carbonated water and syrup but without caffeine. You can choose different flavorings from strawberry, coconut, orange, lemon, and so many more. Other soda drinks don’t have half and half added.

Why do Italian cream sodas curdle?

The curdling happens when you use citrus flavoring. You can use this flavoring instead, Torani Orange Dairy Friendly Syrup.

Can I make these without the Half & Half?

Yes, you can. I realize some people are going without dairy these days. It will still taste great without it, but the flavor and texture will be different.

What are the most popular Italian Soda flavors?

Of course, everyone has their favorite flavor, but I researched the answer to this. In order of popularity, it goes like this: lemon, strawberry, raspberry, cherry, lime, cherry-lime, and the list is even longer. It’s so fun to choose your favorite ones.

How long does the Torani Syrup Flavorings last?

They are shelf-stable for two years, or whatever the bottle has printed on the top of the bottle.

How many flavorings are available by Torani?

Are you ready for this? They have 150 flavorings sold worldwide. You can add the flavoring to coffee, tea, and lemonades, and make your very own soda flavor by mixing your favorite flavors together. Best Flavored Torani Syrups

Final Word

Please let me know if you have your own Italian Cream Soda Recipe? Let me know your favorite flavors, I love hearing from you. It’s all about making memories and treats with family and friends. May God Bless this world, Linda